Amish Country PopcornBallpark ButterSalt Popcorn Salt - 5.5 oz Bottle | Old Fashioned, Non-GMO and Gluten Free (5.5 oz Bottle)

The Amish Country Popcorn Ballpark ButterSalt is a 6 oz seasoning blend designed to give homemade popcorn that iconic movie theater taste. It’s old-fashioned, non-GMO, and gluten-free, making it a great choice for those who want a flavorful but simple seasoning. I tested it with freshly popped Amish Country popcorn to assess flavor, texture, and overall usability.Pros:✅ Rich, buttery flavor replicates classic movie theater popcorn✅ Finely ground salt sticks well to hot popcorn✅ Non-GMO and gluten-free, making it accessible for most diets✅ Versatile seasoning—great for fries, veggies, and other snacks✅ Compact and convenient bottle for easy storage and useCons:❌ High salt content, so a little goes a long way❌ Does not contain real butter, just butter flavoring❌ Better adhesion when used with oil or melted butterPerformance and Usability:This ButterSalt seasoning coats popcorn evenly, especially when added to hot, freshly popped kernels. It delivers a bold, buttery-salty taste, though using too much can make it overly salty. Since it doesn't contain real butter, pairing it with butter or oil enhances the flavor. The fine texture helps it distribute well, but dry popcorn may need a bit of moisture for the salt to adhere properly.Comparison:Compared to pre-packaged microwave popcorn, this offers better control over flavor and saltiness. It competes well with movie theater butter-flavored seasonings, like Kernel Season’s, but with a simpler ingredient list and no artificial colors.Who Is This For?:Perfect for popcorn lovers who enjoy classic buttered popcorn flavor but want more control over ingredients. Great for families, home movie nights, and those who prefer non-GMO, gluten-free seasonings.Conclusion:The Amish Country Popcorn Ballpark ButterSalt is a simple yet flavorful seasoning that brings the movie theater experience home. While it works best with oil or butter, it’s an excellent addition to any popcorn lover’s pantry.

I used to have to buy this in my local Amish store, which is 100 miles away. Not exactly "local". Very happy to now see Amazon sells it.We eat a lot of popcorn, and we used to go to the movies a lot, probably watched over 500 movies in theaters. There is nothing like movie theater popcorn. Nothing. Most "butter" or "movie theater" popcorn seasoning tastes barf. Even from the big-name companies. They smell and taste like bile and vomit. No other way to describe it. This brand really does taste like movie theater popcorn seasoning and has the right balance of seasoning and salt.Don't waste your money on other popcorn seasonings. I already did that for you.

I buy big bags of popcorn and add some of this seasoning which makes it really buttery. Very good taste.Do note that it is salty if you are trying to stay away from salt but makes it taste much better.

The consistency was a little more powdery than expected but taste and quality is good

Great Product and taste

Great taste. Texture is very fine when shaking, so best to apply sparingly. Purchased on Amazon because popcorn butter salt does not appear on local grocery store shelves.

Way too salty, so salty that I would return it if I could. I know other reviewers said it’s not too salty (that’s why I bought it, because of those reviews) but whatever they’re normally eating, it must be an actual salt lick if this seems “less salty” to them. This is like sprinkling plain old table salt on your popcorn. There’s also no butter flavor at all, not even a little. Honestly I feel like I was tricked into spending money on a jar of cheap table salt with yellow food coloring. To be fair, some other reviewers say they really like it, so maybe I got a bad batch. But regardless, in my humble opinion this is an absolute no-thank-you. Did I mention I wish I could return it…well, buyer beware I suppose!

Salt does taste like movie theater salt. But I wouldn’t say it’s all natural(just the butter flavor?). It contains yellow 5 & 6. Which is synthetic dyes even though it’s approved by the FDA. I also tried looking for the ingredients and there is no description anywhere. It’s definitely a treat to use once in while. I wouldn’t say “all natural” how they advertise on slides.