stila Stay All Day® Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Liner | Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner Pencil for Tightlining, Waterline & Smoky Eye Looks | 12-Hour Wear, No Budge & Fade-Proof

this pencil eye liner goes on so smooth. The color is really rich and it stays forever! I’ve worn it as a smudgy eyeliner and an eye shadow. I guess you can wear it on your waterline too but I haven’t tried that yet.

I was so excited to receive this eyeliner because the one I had been using had just seen it's last day and I was ready to try something new. I had been using a really high quality eyeliner by westman atelier which is pricey, but very smooth and non-irritating. I was hoping this would be a good match for it, but after wearing it for a few days, I am a tad on the fence. I have very dry, sensitive eyes and thankfully, this doesn't seem to cause any irritation so that is good. I am able to apply a very thin line on the waterline which is also good, but when trying to draw a line on my lid, the liner didn't glide along as smoothly as I was hoping. It was a little "dotty" and when I tried to smooth it together with my finger like I can with the westman eyeliner, it didn't really budge. It's a good eyeliner that requires a little more effort I think--like I can't just throw it on in a hurry like I normally like to do, but when I take the time to carefully apply with my magnifying mirror and a steady hand, then yes, it does create a very precise line. It did smudge a tiny bit after a few hours that included a workout so it isn't perfectly smudge proof. It takes extra effort to remove it with my makeup remover at the end of the day so overall I guess it is pretty long lasting. I will absolutely keep using it and will finish it up, but I don't know if I am in love with it as I thought I would be. If my opinion changes by the time it runs out, I will definitely update this review.

I love the light sparkle! The color is intense but not obnoxious I wore it for a wedding got lots of compliments!

Easy to apply, but it goes on pretty thick, and it smudges as well. You really have to let it sit for a long time. I do like the dark brown color, but I wish this went on finer and didn't smudge easily when applying.

I am a of these stila gel eye liners. They go on so smooth and look great all day long, even when it is hot and humid outside which usually makes my makeup run. These have really helped my look stay in place all day long. The color is nice and pigmented and is true to color. Definitely going to continue to order these since these are the best thing I have tried so far!

I like how smooth this eyeliner is to apply and that I can get a good blended look with it. It's smudge resistant, not smudge proof.

This stila Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Eye Liner applies so smoothly and precisely that I didn’t need to do any touch up when putting it on; and it also did stay in place all day. The damsel dark brown color is a stronger, bolder, brown than I typically wear. It really makes my eyes pop! I also love this type of roll-up pencil applicator that will never need sharpening!

This stila Stay All Day® Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Eye Liner is Fantastic!It glides on smooth and easy! It doesn't smudge or move all day!I love it!Great Quality!