4Pcs Eyeshadow Stick, Eye Brightener Stick, Glitter Highlighter Eye Liner, Shimmer Creamy Long Lasting Eye Makeup.(1#2#3#4colour)

NOT Thrive! The color of the container is the same and that is ALL! They are way smaller and not at all smooth like Thrive. They are so solidly hard they don't glide onto your lid like Thrive does. Barely any color to them also. Way too shimmery for my old eyelids. You have to push so hard on your lid for any color to come off it actually made my contact fall off my eyeball and it ended up breaking into pieces b/c you're pushing so hard. I even tried heating them with a lighter ( old eyeliner trick) and it still doesn't glide on like thrive. So cheap but still not worth it. Don't waste your money!

I thought I was buying the Thrive brand, but when it was received, it’s actually a separate vendor. This product doesn’t go on as easily as the Thrive products.

They're using the thrive and it's an imposter. The crayon is so hard I had to press way too hard for it going on my eyelid and I wasn't about to press harder. I tried softening the tip on paper so it would go on easier and it's just too hard of a material. I tried all 4 colors as best I could and the light ones don't even show up and the 2 darker shades are so light they don't really show up either. TOTAL WASTE OF MONEY.

This eye pencil is so hard I couldn’t use it on my eyes. Very dry. The application didn’t go on smooth like the product advertised. You can see from the other comments we all had the same experience. I can imagine who gave them 5 stars….

I love the colors but they could be slightly softer. I've tried heating a bit with my blow dryer.

These eyeshadow suck … the product is hard which doesn’t allow me to apply to my lids easily. Two of the sticks are broken at the bottom so I can’t lengthen the shadow. Don’t waste your money.

I thought I was buying thrive eye brightener but I was fooled. This stuff is so hard to put on and looks like crap. I won’t be fooled again.

Nothing like the real product from thrive makeup, like they portray to be. I tried using these this morning, before work! You couldn’t even see the pigment of the the color. Highly DO not recommend. Will definitely go through the thrive website.