Stacy Adams Men's Kimball-Cap Toe Monk Strap Slip-on Loafer

This shoe fits very large! I usually fit a 10-10.5 comfortably. I plan on wearing without socks, so ordered the 10 and it was huge! I was worried even a 9.5 would have been too large, based on the fit of the 10. I exchanged it for a 9 and it fits perfectly. So I would recommend ordering a full size smaller than you normally wear, unless you'll be wearing thick socks.It looks great! One minor complaint is that the darker part of the toe cap doesn't fade to the redder part of the shoe as smoothly as I'd like; a more gradual fade would have been nice. The 10 they sent me was the wrong color (saddle tan) which still looked good, but not the richer redder chestnut color I ordered. So even if the shoe fit right the first time, I still would have had to exchange it for the correct color.Lastly, the two shoes I ordered (the 10 and the 9 I exchanged the 10 for) were styled differently. The 9 has a real toe cap, made of a separate piece of leather layered over the toe. The 10 has an "etched" cap, where it's actually one piece of leather, with a dark line etched across which gives the impression of a cap but really isn't. All the photos on amazon show the etched version. It's something to be aware of that you may get a real toe cap or a faux toe cap. Everything else about the shoe design appears to be the same. I prefer the real toe cap, which is what I got in the end, so I'm happy.If you're willing to put some effort into making some possible exchanges to make sure you get the right size, color, and style, this is one of the best looking shoes I've seen. If you can't be bothered with the potential hassle, you'd be better served buying a different shoe.

First opening the package, I noticed that the color was a little off. I had ordered Chestnut, and the color ended up in between the two brown options, Chestnut, and Tan. That being said, the shoes were beautiful, so I was willing to overlook the color discrepancy.However, after wearing them only one day to the office. (and taking them off while sitting at my desk) I noticed that the dark color on the toe that made them look so nice had started to rub off. It wasn't stained leather as I expected, but a layer of wax(?) that is easily removed. I was able to rub it off with just a bit of pressure from my finger, but will also rub off by just bumping into the other shoe.Highly disappointed, I really liked the look of these shoes. Especially disappointed at this price point.(>$100)I'll be returning them.Edit: Rather than returning these, I turned them into a little art project. I used a little mahogany and black cream and hard wax polish to add a patina, and they looked better than I hoped! I added some diluted ox blood dye and changed them from mud brown to a deeper mahogany color. Unfortunately, these shoes have started me down the path of becoming a shoe snob. I've had them for a while now and wear them to the office every other day. Still seem to be holding up pretty well!

They look very elegant and pretty comfortable. I ended up ordering a size smaller for all of my guys (four of them). None of them complained of sore feet at the end of the day. All of them danced and did a good amount of walking.

I would give zero stars if I could. These shoes are FAKE!I repeat these shoes are FAKE. Do yourself a favor and turn around.If you dont mind fake shoes, I recommend getting half a size smaller. Because the shoe also ran way too big I had my shoes returned. The return was quick and easy.

I bought these in a size 11, and they looked like clown shoes. As well, when I returned them and tried to purchase a size 10 or 10.5, the price suddenly went up from $54 to $120. Be very careful on sizing, as it differs from pretty much every other line of shows. And to pay over 2x for a half size down feels too much like a bait and switch.

Quality of these where beyond what I expected to be honest. I love ever detail of these shoes! I will say though on the buckle, there's this metal cylinder that gaurds the buckle that clatters... yeah they need to fix that lol but other than that these are solid

I LOVE how it looks but fits really big. Also annoying that if I go from size 12 to size 11.5 the price goes up like $35 which to me I dont wanna pay just because their sizing sucks . Great looking shoe though. Not super comfy soles like other Stacy Adams I have worn though. Would really love the company to send me smaller size for same cost...

The color is superb and the quality is excellent.