Muhammad: A Very Short Introduction

Dr. Jonathan Brown has published research in pre-Islamic Arabic poetry, Islamic law, and hadith (prophetic traditions - he has published at least two books on this topic as well). Well-versed in traditional accounts and contemporary studies to the Prophet's biography, he takes the same approach to introduce his readers to the subject. One finds that a reader will directly or indirectly be acquainted to many an approach contained in texts ranging from traditional to the modern including Ibn Hisham and Ibn Kathir to the other extreme such as Patricia Crone and Michael Cook. Additionally, other works, such as Ptolemy's account, content similar to Robert Hoyland's "Seeing Islam as Others Saw It", which is a very resourceful collection of narratives from non-Muslim sources regarding the Muslims in the seventh and eighth centuries, and present day accounts in the media also seem to have been utilized. Dr. Brown does not limit research to only sira accounts though but also delves into pre-Islamic Near Eastern history to provide context for several practices of the Arabs which are now anathema to us in the modern world. Many a time, this removes the inherent bias that one comes with to study Islam (this bias can either be for or against Islam). Given the plethora of research on the subject and the fact that it runs a wide gamut, Dr. Brown has done amazingly well to keep the introduction short, yet the reader would come out no less educated about the topic than any other book on the subject. And that is why this work is a class in itself, and has the potential to become an introductory text for college courses to the Prophet. The book is divided into three chapters. Chapter 1 takes the reader into the Arabian milieu in which the Prophet lived and acquaints the reader to the traditional account of his biography. Dr. Brown plays no games and walks through with the caveat that we must study the "legend", the word repeated thrice in first five pages. This is important because if you have a Muslim neighbor, you would be reading a book to get a handle on what he believes in as well as an objective understanding of the pertinent issues with that account. Chapter 1 accomplishes the goal of telling you what a Muslim would believe in. Chapter 2 steps into the actual problems with the accounts. These vary from authenticity of the historical reports to miraculous incidents to similarities with the accounts of other prophets. As the second chapter unfolds, Dr. Brown, relying on recent scholarship, starts introducing the readers to the problems inherent in the account, contributing factors, and the parts of the biography that ought to be subtracted. He gives quite some details about the earliest biography, that of Ibn Ishaq, and how it may have been redacted by Ibn Hisham to produce a version favorable to the ruling elite. Additionally, several accounts are favorable to sunnis than shiites, such as the Prophet's uncle Abbas was closer to the Prophet and more aware of his condition than Ali. In some cases, he does not take the reader to a conclusion, simply introduces to the problem perhaps because the data is not enough yet. He narrates for instance that the change of qiblah has been thought to be a political motivation by some modern historians than a religious issue. In controversial issues, taking the Prophet's marriage with Aisha as an example, he takes the reader into the social milieu of that time outside of the Arabian peninsula and compares with the practices of non-Arabian regions (such as those of the Byzantine empire) to set the context. However, he takes Bukhari's account and does not address other competing accounts of Aisha's marriage with the Prophet, justifiably because it's a "short introduction". In chapter 1, it was stated that Muslim accounts held that a sanctuary existed in Mecca. In chapter 2, he cites Ptolemy who had recorded centuries earlier that Arabs did in fact have a building which was the center of their religious life. Similarly, a synopsis of Hagarism, which many Muslims find extremely offensive, is provided along with the non-Muslim accounts that address the historicity of the Prophet. It must be kept in mind that quite some research on non-Muslim accounts was published after Hagarism (e.g. in Robert Hoyland's Seeing Islam) and thus many readers were unaware of the other non-Muslim accounts when Hagarism was published. Some later scholars (such as Neal Robinson in his book on the Quran) have also used those contemporary non-Muslim sources to negate Hagarism's account. Chapter 3 introduces the readers to the current day issues, such as the fatwa from Khomeini for Salman Rushdie's execution. He provides the background as to how Khomeini would arrive at it with a clear indication that many other clerics would reach the same conclusion. Some issues related to the current Islamic culture and Muslim life are also discussed, which includes Prophet's images, and small sections on seeing him in dreams, and modern biographies of the Prophet which depict him more as a historical figure than a sacred one (e.g. Husayn Haykal's biography). All references are listed at the end of the book for further research. By all means, I do not agree with some other reviewers that it is a pro-Islamic narrative. In fact, many a Muslim are quite likely to find it anti-Islam specifically due to negation of many events that Muslims otherwise hold sacred. Change of qiblah is an obvious one. To bring this issue in chapter 2 and state that this has been concluded so by modern historians could be considered offensive by some Muslims, and could also have been avoided by Dr. Brown. Nonetheless, Dr. Brown simply states it and moves on. Dr. Brown also "introduces" and does not always go in depth into many issues to necessarily drive a conclusion, which I would have liked but given the expectation that it was a short introduction, I am content to live without (the qiblah issue itself being a case in point.) Quite a reasonable part of what would take one months of readings (if not years) of several scholars to get the breadth of the issues surrounding the biography of the Prophet is covered here. Of course, it is "short" and just an "introduction" so it only covers the breadth without delving into much depth. For any in-depth issues, references in the book are a good starting point, although many topics would eventually require specialized research often in Arabic source materials. I sincerely hope that we can have this as a model for all religious introductory books. I would like to study Jesus, Bible, Buddha, Hinduism and other religions (and even non-Religious topics) in the same format. All in all, it was $8 and a few hours very well spent!

The product itself physically is solid. I enjoy the feeling of the print. The contents of the text itself was really interesting and I learned a lot about the prophet muhammad. I understood much more about my former religion (Christianity) through the lens of a religion like Islam developing through out it's history and the religious mythology is very eye-opening in comparison to the Christian myths. This book is great for secular people.

I found the author's organization of this book to be fairly good. Part 1 is a summary of the Prophet's life and character from Ibn Ishaq's book, the standard source of Prophetic biography, written in the 700s. Part 2 offers a scholarly critique of this narrative (mainly from the western perspective). Part 3 covers how Muslims have traditionally seen the Prophet over the centuries. Part 1 was impressive in that the author managed to squeeze quite a bit of detail in a limited space. For whatever reason, it does include some of the less common material that doesn't usually come up in the Prophetic biography (like the correspondence between Heraclius and the priest of Constantinople). I found Part 2 to be the most interesting, taking us into the world of late antiquity to explain some aspects of the Prophet's biography that might seem strange to modern readers(i.e. the ubiquitous presence of jinn, the immense reverence that his companions had for his physical person, his marriages etc. ). The section also introduces us to the modern western critique of the traditional biography- which allegedly finds elements of the later Sunni-Shia struggle or disputes between Muslims and Christians reflected in it(while still accepting the broad outlines of the narrative). The author convincingly refutes some of the more sweeping, fringe critiques- such as Michael Cook's thesis that first century of Muslim history is simply a massive forgery by later Muslims. Part 3, although full of interesting tidbits (dalail khayrat was the most widely read book in 18th century Egypt, after the Quran) was the least impressive; I thought it was too short and some of the points, especially regarding the punishments for blasphemy should have been developed much further. However this could easily be made up by reading Annemarie Schimmel's "And Muhammad is his Messenger." Over all a good book. The only drawback is it's small size and the necessary limitations this imposes. Like the author's book on Hadith, it is sympathetic but not apologetic. We need more books like these.

I really liked this quick intro to the life of the Prophet Muhammad. It reads like a story at the beginning, giving an Islamic historical account, and then begins a discussion about some of the pros and cons in modern Islamic thought. It's a good place to begin.

Very informative book by Dr. Jonathan Brown that breaks down the biography of Prophet Muhammad from an Islamic POV and a non-Islamic POV. Highly recommend everyone to read it!

The book reads like a junior high essay. I'm not sure what the author's background, but I get the impression he is writing for team Muhammad. I'm also not sure that is a bad thing, but I prefer to at least think the author is objective.

A great book to recommend for anyone that wants a snapshot into the life of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) in under 1 hour.

A pithy precise and very true to spirit book . The journey The author has taken to to embrace the truth and translate it in this book is simply profound

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this as it encapsulates the Prophets life in a very understandable way. Thank you for the hard work.

Perfect.

The most concise book about the life of Prophet Mohammad PBUH. It includes all the major events which happended in his life and it definitely gives anyone a brief introduction about the Proohets life. But for details about the different events other books should studied.

fast delivery, very happy with my order!

This is an excellent short story of the prophet Muhammad. A must read,i would recommend to Muslims n non Muslims.