Palladio Liquid Eyeliner, Highly Pigmented and Waterproof Eyeliner, For Intense Eye Definition, Smear-proof Eyeliner Liquid, Includes Easy Grip Wand and Felt Tip Eyeliner Applicator, Aquamarine

I am always hunting for the perfect eyeliner. To me the important criteria are availability of good basic colors (do people really need teal or silver or lavender eyeliner? I don't), ease of application, and long wear. Palladio scores well in all three areas.First, the colors: They have black, black/brown, and navy, as well as a few more shimmery shades that I don't use. I currently have the black and black brown shades, and have had the navy in the past. They are exactly the rich colors you expect them to be.Second, I love the ease of application. It's eyeliner liquid with a felt tip applicator. To me, that's the ideal form eyeliner should take. I find that eyeliner pencil doesn't glide on smoothly or intensely enough, brush applicators are hard to use for even application, and eyeliner markers tend to start out wet and then get dryer as you apply it. Ugh! But Palladio, that I've been using for ages, applies smoothly each time and stays smooth in the bottle for a long, long time. The felt tip is just the right thickness so that you can control the line, from fine to wide depending on how you use it. The top of the bottle is thin, which I find easiest to manipulate.And finally, this stuff lasts all day once applied and dry. Although it is not waterproof, it is smudge-proof and I have never had it melt or bleed. Granted, I have dry skin, so I don't know if having oily eyelids would make it smudge or not. But for me, it lasts perfectly, yet is easy to remove with eye makeup remover, either the oily or non-oily kind.All in all, Palladio is the perfect eyeliner for me, and I recommend it highly.

This eyeliner has a firm tip that helps keep your hand steady while applying it, and it offers excellent quality and long-lasting wear. I really like it.

Goes on smoothly, great color green, stays on, doesn't smudge, and washes off easily

It doesn’t come with a fine fine brush.

Paladio eye liner. This is my second bottle. I really like this product. It's easy to use and doesn't flake off. It does remove easily though if you need to.

Love this blue eyeliner ! I have always used this color by Prestige but they phased out - this is pretty much identical ♥️ goes in great and dries well with no smudging

Hurts where I applied on the area of my eyelids and has such an ugly tip. Has a weird applicator tip that doesn’t help you apply properly. And I have always been using a liquid eyeliner for 7 years but this one has one of the most awkward eyeliner tip

I received the order timely. I wish the eyeliner were finer. Overall, it is a nice one.