4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara, Lengthening and Thick, Long Lasting, Waterproof & Smudge-Proof, Hypoallergenic Formula 2 Pack Black

Love this! It does what it’s supposed to. Doesn’t clump like most mascaras!!

I actually bought this mascara by mistake. I thought it was a two-step fiber mascara like one I usually purchase. It was a bit cheaper than the one I normally get, so I thought I'd try it out. When I received it, I realized that the two tubes included were the same, you just got two tubes, not one with the primer/sealer and the other with the fibers. Oh well. But I figured I'd try it out and see how it worked.While it doesn't really compare as far as building up volume and length, I have to say I really like this mascara because it does what I believed was impossible for me - it does not smudge! Not a bit!I have tried so many mascaras over the decades (I'm old) that claimed to be smudge-proof, only to come away disappointed and raccoon-eyed, sometimes by the end of the day, sometimes by the first hour of wear. The lashes on one of my eyes tend to tilt down-wards, even though I curl them beforehand, so the mascara eventually starts to smudge to some extent, no matter what I do. I found the two-step fiber mascaras gave me the best results, but even they were not entirely smudge-proof sometimes.This particular mascara actually stays on, even when it's hot and humid. I have been wearing it now for a couple months and have been really pleased. Though I wouldn't recommend it for making your lashes really full or long, I would definitely recommend it as an everyday mascara that defines your lashes, and stays put.Removing it isn't hard either, I use a make-up remover cream, and that works fine, without much effort.Product arrived in a nice, sturdy box, and was intact. Recommend this product and seller.

Tried this on a whim, as I was having issues with other brands and my eye allergies. LOVE IT! Very light weight, buildable and it doesn't clump (unless I decided to not remove my make up the night before.. even then it'll build but just get thick when it wasn't removed.). I bought some for my daughter and she's hooked now too!

So, I tried this mascara, and let me tell you, it’s like a fairy godmother for your lashes, but only if she’s in a good mood. One coat? Chef’s kiss. My blonde, short, and straight lashes suddenly had length and definition without resembling a daddy longlegs convention.But then I got cocky. Two coats? Eh, pushing it. Three coats? Suddenly my lashes looked like they were auditioning for a Tim Burton movie. Not exactly the vibe I was going for.And because it’s a fiber mascara, those little lash fibers like to go rogue. By lunchtime, I had a sprinkle of them under my eyes, like confetti from a party I wasn’t invited to.That said, I’m sticking to one coat until the tubes run dry. If you have longer lashes, this might be your new holy grail. But for us short-lashed folks? It’s more like “holy... maybe.”Check out my before-and-after photo to witness the transformation. Spoiler: no arachnids were harmed in the making of this look.

I used to love this mascara but my last 2 purchases have been disappointing. I think they changed the formula. The first time I bought it, my lashes looked amazing and it was long lasting and the tube seemed to last forever. Now, it seems wet and clumpy and smudges like mad. After a few weeks, it seems like there's no product left in the tube or it has dried up. Really disappointed. Time to find something different.

Short version: Buy it. You won't regret it. (Unless you want waterproof, which this is not, but it's still a great value.)Long version: Definitely makes my eyelashes look fuller & longer. Beats every drugstore mascara I've tried. Not sure how it compares to higher-end ones, I don't really buy those.The one I got seems water resistant, but not waterproof. If my eyes get watery, it doesn't smear, but if I splash my face w/water, it will. I don't mind, I wasn't looking for a waterproof mascara anyways. If you are, this probably isn't the one you want. It's hard to remove w/water & soap. I use makeup remover wipes, it removes easily.The best part for me: I don't mess up as much using this mascara. If I accidentally blink before it dries it doesn't get all over my face. Not sure how this is even possible: if I accidentally tap the brush slightly on my face, there's little to no transfer (to a point, obviously) and when there is, I can usually wipe it off quickly without having to redo whatever makeup it landed on top of. Yes I can be clumsy, but this stuff helps make that less obvious.It can get clumpy if I curl my eyelashes again after applying. With a very light first layer, after it dries, it doesn't get clumpy if I curl once more. After that I apply a couple more times. Looks better than any other way I've tried, and better than any other mascara I've tried.I will be ordering more as soon as possible. This is my new regular.

I have tried for years to find a mascara that is not irritating and that truly by the end of the day has not smudged and moved from my upper lashes to below my eyes. I love this because it's light and stays in places. No smudges, no messes, no black eye appearance.

Been searching for good mascara. Have paid from $20 to $40 for singe tubes. None were good. Disappointed. Decided to try this couple of weeks ago 4 stars and 2 tubes for less than $15