Pacifica Vegan Collagen Fluffy Lash Mascara – Black Thickening & Lengthening Mascara with Plant Fibers, Full Fluffy Lashes, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, 0.24 oz

I love this mascara. It thickens my lashes naturally and doesn’t rub off.

This Pacifica Vegan Collagen Fluffy mascara does it all! It's light, the coverage and lift is good. Flaking is minimal to none. It doesn't smear easy. I've cried wearing this stuff and when I check in the mirror I didn't have the dreaded racoon eyes. And the best part of all, it's perfect for sensitive eyes! My eyes are incredibly sensitive, even sensitive formula mascara makes my eyes burn. Not so with this, no burning, no irritation, no bad ingredients. It's awesome!

This mascara itself it great! I had been looking for a more earth-friendly mascara in a glass tube for some time. It’s not the most eco-conscious choice out there, but I don’t see myself fiddling with powders or waxes to do my mascara, which is what all the ones in truly recyclable/compostable containers seem to be. The mascara is great, a true black that is thick and doesn’t smudge or flake with hours of wear. The packaging is gorgeous. I love the color and weight of the tube, it feels so heavy and luxe. But the brush doesn’t work for me. The shape of it (skinny in the middle and fat on the ends) leaves my center lashes stuck together with big globs of mascara. I thought it was the mascara at first, but then I tried using the old spoolie from my last tube of Great Lash and suddenly the mascara was easy to apply and looked great. If the brush was a different shape I’d give this mascara 5 stars.

Works well- clean and cruelty free. Smooth application- not clumpy or too intense- but noticeable. It rarely smudges and has never flaked. Natural (not that super separated look that some like) I have a hard time finding clean/cruelty free/ affordable (goes on sale often enough) mascara that doesn’t flake or smudge. Look at the price per ounce on mascaras- it’s a racket.

I’ve used this brand’s other two mascaras for years and thought I’d try this one, but I haaaatttteee it. The formula is super goopy and you can’t really tell in the photos but the wand is a very awkward shape. I think the wand would only work well on eyes that are 50% wider than mine and shallow-set 😅 I tried it many times and found it completely unfixable - had to take it all off and wear something else in order to not look like a child sneaking into her mom’s makeup for the first time. I gave up and started using a different wand with it. Kind of a pain but it helped significantly. Even with a decent wand (and ignoring that that’s a bit of a pain) the formula still makes this a bad product. Waaaay too thick and gloopy. I’m still using it (on days I don’t have to look great) because $ and waste, but I loathe it every application, and I can’t wait to run out of either it or my limited patience with it. There’s significant cleanup effort required each time: brushing it out, tweezing my lashes back apart, brushing again, and cleaning up my eyelids. Do not recommend.

Mascara is fine but the brush does not work for me

Originally purchased this in a holiday set with a few other brands of mascara. Tho some ended being the stand out favorite. The brush is a little on the thicker size, and it can tend to be clumpy, however there is definitely more nourishing benefits that you can feel when you put on this mascara. It seems to glide on and hydrate your lashes. If you’re concerned with clumps you can always use an eyelash brush or spoolie after. One downside - the actual container is glass. Which can feel nice and luxurious until you drop it on the ground and it shatters (and you cry over spilled mascara… I know from experience). Just be careful when handling.

I can believe this excellent mascara Love it!

love this mascara! finally one that doesn’t bother my eyes

I like the mascara, it goes on smooth, is dark black, has no fragrance, and my eyes have no sensitive/allergic reaction to it. However, I'm not a fan of the wand, the design of the wand makes me get mascara on my eyelids and on the skin under my eyes. I must wait until it dries and wipe it off my skin with a q-tip. I wish it had just a normal wand.

Je l'adore

Takes a long time to put on enough mascara to show, brush is too big.

I have tried a couple other Pacifica mascaras and I absolutely loved them. But they dicontinued one of them and the other one is never in stock. I decided to try this one while it was on sale. I don't expect natural mascaras to work like the ones that have a boat load of chemicals, so my expectation is low. The ingredients are great in this one and I love that it comes in a glass tube. But my goodness this mascara was weird... It didn't create fluffiness, the wand took some getting used to and it took many coats to get a half decent look. But then it started to actually curl some of the tips of my eye lashes down the opposite way?! I have short curled lashes... And it didn't matter how much or how little mascara I used - it still made them curl the opposite way, I even bought an eyelash curler because I didn't want to waste the product... I tried other mascaras under and over it and still no luck