Gemini_mall® 12Pcs Professional Twist Up Retractable Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil Eyebrow Pencil Set (Black)

does the job. Like it. price is good for 12pack.

These are a fantastic bargain. Took a chance as there were no reviews, but they are really cheap, so nothing to lose. Very pleased, and they are a really soft pencil. I would have preferred a slightly lighter brown colour, but I apply it lightly so it's fine. I use it as an eyebrow pencil, don't know about using it as eyeliner as I haven't tried it for that purpose.

No Negative.I love the quality. No smudge, glides on easy. Lasts all day. Lots in the pack so they last a long time.Last but not least the price is excellent.

Don't know why I ordered 12 of them but here we go haha. Stays well, I use the brown on my eyebrows then a brush to fade them out so I'm not going round with slugs lol

It falls apart very easily. I’ve taken the liner out and put it in my glimmer stick and it’s ok. I ordered brown but got black. Oh well for the money I’ll use them but won’t re Oder.

Just what I was looking for.. quick delivery. No issues at all

Rubbish

Packaging is cheap and the eyeliner breaks easy but it's pigmented and for the price and amount you get you really can't go wrong