Kirkland Signature Walkers Premium Shortbread Selection Gift Tin, 4.6 Pound, Packaging May Vary

A buy these regularly from Amazon. Also, my niece buys them and sends them to me.

I have ordered these last year and twice this year. Many of the round cookies are always broken; the others are not. The finger cookies have far more sugar than the other two variety of cookies. The round cookies are far more broken and I am unsure as to why. A few of the triangle cookies have cracked; none the less they are very tasty. One review wrote that the taste with Kirkland is different than the ones direct from Scotland and this is true. The finger cookies are the most changed; and the Kirkland brand is better and far more sugar is involved! These are not broken, on the several times I've ordered them thru this site. I will continue to order these cookies; I'm afraid I am too greedy as the last bunch I ordered I gave at least half a way; due to my weight gain of eating the last entire batch of Kirkland shortbread cookies from Walkers! I will probably order them again at Christmas and eat some and give the rest away. Hopefully I will loose the ten pounds I've gained since ordering the last batch! They are so good and my will power is low. I'm laughing; I've no history of diabetes and had lost a great deal of weight last year, actually was quite thin. So I need to lose ten to 12 pounds so I can get into my small clothes again and will do so by NOT ordering again until Christmas and I will give many away. They will make great Christmas present to friends, colleagues.

Best shortbread after homemade.

Depending on the Amazon vendor, this large tin of cookies can be a real bargain over other markets and stores. It is an abundant supply! The cookies are delicious and do not, in my opinion, contain an overly large amount of sugar. But, it seems almost inevitable that there will be broken cookies among them. Usually the shortbread fingers and triangles hold up well, but the different round cookies are very fragile, thus, the box as a whole may not be an ideal gift, but some separately wrapped cookie packages within might serve well!

Galletas deliciosas

We all know Walkers makes the best shortbread, so there’s no question that the cookies are delicious. I’m glad I ordered a “trial” box (in the tin) rather than waiting until closer to Christmas. (I had been thinking of giving them as a gift.) I won’t be ordering more for presents, but I am secretly happy that because of the few broken cookies, I will have to just eat them myself!

Classic product. Classy packaging with large metal tin box.

Come on Kirkland! I read the reviews & many people were unhappy with the condition of their broken box of cookies since 2024. I got a can of cookies in Dec 2024 and they had minimal amount of broken cookies. So, I recently reordered thinking my cookies would arrive perfectly in my beautiful can…….wrong! I think there were 3 sets of cookies ( round, triangle & rectangles) for 12. The round & triangles were all broken to some degree. The rectangle cookies fared the best.Kirkland, get your baking/ marketing/ sales/ shipping/ pricing teams together and get this problem figured out.We are tolerating this because the breakage does not hinder the taste but you cannot offer your guest a shortbread cookie looking like this.You need to give every person that informed you of this issue a credit and thank them for being a loyal customer.We love your product, we want to support you & your company !