Palladio Retractable Eye Pencil Pure Black

This product has replaced what I can no longer buy from Estee Lauder. It is actually a better eye liner and it doesn't smear. I have sensitive skin and have no problems with this eye liner. The price is great. I like the mechanical aspect because I don't like the kind you sharpen as they always break off. This product exceeded my expectation. I have tried other brands and will not deviate from this brand since they now have me buying this product for as long as they sell it. I have since tried a few other colors. I like the black but have tried the olive, the brown/black and the navy blue. I also like their lip liners like this and plum is my favorite color of those. I am less picky on lip liner than eye liner. This one get 5 stars.

Oh my. I have a hard time finding a eyeliner that was a wasn't pencil I have found that I liked till this one. I've always used liquid. This product isn't to soft or to hard. I love that its retractable.

I use this eyeliner all of the time. I usually get it from Sally's beauty supply for a little over $5 and it never runs and it lasts all day. I gave this product 4 stars instead of a full 5 bc I thought I was getting a better deal by ordering online. Perhaps I mistook the description but I thought I was ordering 3 retractable eyeliner pencils for $10, but I only received one. So one of these on amazon cost me twice as much as one would cost me at the store, so I am keeping the item since I will use it anyway, but I will not order it again.

Liove how easy this goes on and stays on!

Love this eyeliner. Will buy more! Applies do easy and stays on!

I live this eyeliner. I normally buy it from Sallys but easier to order it here on Amazon. The eyeliner is waterproof & stays on great!

I bought this in blue and it glides on easily, however I then bought in black and it does not go on smoothly. I think it may be an old or expired product.

I used this to line my upper inner eyelids, praying my eyes would not be too sensitive to it.Success! My eyes are not itching or burning, and the eyeliner is staying put. I am happy! :)This is smudgeproof eyeliner in a retractable pencil - I love this kind of pencil over the old fashioned wooden ones, which I can never get to a decent point without shaving away a lot of product. This is much better!