Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil, Medium Brown, 1 Count

I absolutely love this eyebrow pencil! I've been using it for years and I was originally buying it from Target and other local stores until they stopped carrying it. Thankfully, I can still find it on Amazon.The formula goes on super smooth, and the blonde shade is perfect—not too light, not too dark. With other brands, I always struggled to find the right tone, but this one is spot on for a natural look.Another feature I really appreciate is the built-in brow brush on the other end. It’s incredibly handy, especially when I’m traveling and want to keep things minimal.Pros:- Smooth application- Perfect natural blonde shade- Built-in brow brush for convenience- Great for travel- Long-time reliable productCons:- The pencil can break if you twist it up too far—just be careful not to extend it too muchThis is my go-to brow pencil and I’m so glad I can still get it online. If you're looking for a natural-looking blonde brow pencil that applies easily and travels well, this is it. Highly recommend!

I’ve been using the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil in Deep Brown for years, and it’s my absolute go-to! I love how natural it looks; it's the perfect shade that blends seamlessly with my original eyebrows. The pencil glides on smoothly, and the formula is long-lasting without smudging. The precision tip makes it easy to fill in any sparse areas without looking overdone, and it gives me that soft, defined look I love. I wouldn't choose anything else because it gives me exactly what I want every time. If you’re looking for an eyebrow pencil that’s easy to use and gives a natural finish, this one is a must-try!

I have used this for years. It can rub off easily, but I Ike it. I like that it’s easy to apply and it’s not too dark.

I purchased eyebrow pencils from 5 different brands trying to find my new eyebrow pencil. My old brand changed their formula and now their light brown has hints of red in it which doesn't match my roots.Of all the ones I tested, this color was the best match for my hair. I consider my hair a medium brown color. My camera makes the pencil look like it has a bit of red in it, but in person its a nice medium brown. It's perfect for me but this is BLONDE so I think it would be too dark for blondes. It went on smooth, didn't crumble, was easy to apply, and has good coverage. Also the way the pencil is designed it will retain a sharp-ish tip for fine detailed lines or eyebrow wing tips which is a huge plus.Only con I can anticipate is that since the brow color material is poured in a skinnier thickness that I may use up this pencil quicker than other pencils because there just isn't as much product in each tube. However I'm willing to sacrifice some longevity because the color matches!

Probably the best of many I've tried for blondes as I was able to use it lightly to fill in and the other end brush helped to diffuse any strong color buildup. It is so hard to find something good for ladies who were blondes all their lives but are now white or gray. Everything is just a shade too dark. But this beats any others so far and I would recommend if you keep a light touch.

This pencil creates the most natural looking brows, you can even draw in stray hairs like I like to do at the inner corners. I used to use Anastasia Dipbrow but I feel that's a heavy product and gives a more painted-on kind of look. Lately I like a natural look and this pencil is what I prefer. It's so easy to use, stays sharp, and stays put despite my dewy skin. The only drawback is I don't think you get much product so you have to replace often.

I just received and used the eyebrow pencil. Color and texture is great . I would have given it 5 stars except that the tip fell off when I opened it ( about 1/2”)….and that is a lot of product to lose. I do like it enough though to reorder and give it another try. I’m hoping the company sees this review and addresses the problem. I never had that happen before with eyebrow pencils.

This is THE best eyebrow pencil! Glides on with minimal expertise required! Love that it’s not a thin line so looks more real!!!