WonderskinEyeliner Pencil, 1440 Longwear Black Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof, Sharpenable & Smudge Proof

I have used teal eye liner for many years, I have used various brands too as brands stop doing teal. My last eye liner was so soft it transferred to my upper lid not a great look.I was apprehensive buying this product, but when it arrived I was impressed with colour, its a proper teal. I followed instructions when applying it the first time, smudging where I wanted and then let it dry, it was soft to apply, no pulling on ,y eye lids tick, a lovely colour tick. I wore it all day and it didn't transfer to upper lids tick no fading no smudging, brilliant. I never wear makeup overnight but I had to taste if it was still OK in the morning and sure enough it still looked perfect, and so easy to wash off. I'm very impressed with this product.

I think I just found my new favourite eyeliner! I have somewhat watery, hooded eyes, which don’t work well with most pencil eyeliners. Usually by the end of the day it’s worn off. This Wonderskin product is a game changer! I love that it can be smudged or blended when first applied, or if left to set it gives a crisp, sharp line that doesn’t budge at all, it lasts all day and night until removed with make up remover. The Brown Sugar colour is a lovely matte brown, and a little softer and more natural for day-to-day wear than black, and it glides on easily (even on aging skin). I also used it to tight line under my lashes, and again this lasted well, so it’s really versatile too. I can see this giving great value for money, as one application per wear is all you need.

Nice and soft , good colour and does not hurt the eyes

Love this product. No smudges and stays on all day

As far as a product not shifting, this eye liner pencil is long-lasting. You can rely on it to stay on exactly where you put it on your skin, and the density of colour is lovely.The sharpness of the nib soon dulls however, and it is simply impossible to sharpen the pencil. I’ve tried putting it in the fridge to harden prior to sharpening but still no luck. It breaks off repeatedly and now I’m down to a tiny pencil and have hardly used it.Measuring this problem - one that many people who have used it experience - against what I feel is quite a pricey eye pencil, I’d be hesitant to purchase again because of it.

Colour is lovely. Very easy to apply.

I bought the dark brown eyeliner because I can not get liner to stay in place. This I will not be buying again, it would not go onto my eyes, it clumped and flaked all down my face as if the pencil had dried up and was brittle. I tried numerous times to glide it on, to not avail. I tried to smudge the clumps into a line but it just flaked off. I even sharpened the pencil (or tried to sharpen it) but it made no difference. It was a complete waste of money.

Why did you choose this product over others?:Great x super long lasting x