Erinde[2PCS] Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Set, Long Lasting Cream Eyeliner Gel, High-Intensity Pigments Smudge-Proof Eye Liner Makeup, Water-Resistant Eyeliner with 4PCS Eyeliner Brushes (Balck & White)

For the price, this isn’t a bad gel liner at all.It does need a little building up to get an intense black line, but….once on, it really stays put. As I’m currently suffering from hayfever watery eyes, this is a real plus!I was really quite disappointed not to get the two promised brushes though. All I got in my pack was what I assume was the tiny stubby plastic handle of what I guess must have been one of the little brushes. Not the end of the world, as I have my own brush to use, but be aware you may not get a brush(es)!

I love this but if your using on your waterline you kinda need to put a thick amount or else its streaky, and even then it is smudgy by the end of the day. Other then that I like it.

Its nice lasts long

I spent one hour experimenting with this one. The first time I used it, there was much smearing. My luck with eyeliners and my oily, hooded and crinkled eyelids were usual. However, I soon realized that if I put on my waterproof liquid shadow (nude color) before applying the liner, I get a lot of staying power! Lovely! I usually try black liners, but I remembered the photo of me as a young woman wearing brown eyeliner. It looks softer than that dark color yet has a body and can take shape. I am more of a blonde now, and my eyes are hazel and amber in color. I have a light color skin for an olive-complexion woman. I do not need dark, dark. I can see black mascara, and only to enhance, not overpower.This eye makeup stayed on for hours. There would be a problem if I had cried, but not like so many other products I have tried. I have that problem with my eyelids, so this is the best it gets. I removed it with a cream eye makeup remover that isn't oily. This formula does not make me sensitive or irritated. It was relatively easy to remove it, but it did require some rubbing. That is why I use oil at times to resist that irritation. But I am OK with this at this point.This eyeliner is an excellent price. There is a lot of this creamy substance in the jar that dries on your skin. The brushes are easy to use and take up no space. (Having one-liner brush cleaned, the other ready to clean, is very convenient. I would get a plastic bag to keep all three items together. (I have a thing about loose parts).This liner set is an excellent gift item too. The box is perfect for that—a lovely thing for you and updating your look!Enjoy!

Maybe gel eyeliner is supposed to be thick, but this was so gloopy and hard to apply, I felt like I was putting Wite-Out on my eyes. And not brand-new Wite-Out but the stuff you find in the deep dark recesses of your college desk. It was, as other reviewers noted, waterproof. And vaseline proof. And major brand name eye makeup remover proof. And soap proof. This stuff did not want to come off my fingers or the brush when I was trying to clean them off. It stuck in the corners of my eyes making me look like I had sleep boogers in them.I'm giving it 3 stars only I'm not a power makeup wearer so it's possible I just don't know how to apply makeup. And also, maybe because I'm no longer trendy, the white was just a poor choice for me. Your mileage may vary but this was a big miss for me.