Natural Farm Collagen Sticks for Dogs (6 Inch, 25 Pack), Odor-Free Long Lasting Chews & Rawhide Alternative - 95% Collagen, Low Fat, High Protein - Best Dental Dog Treats - Medium & Large Dogs

I don't know why these have a 4.2 rating because they're great. My puppy adores them, I love the long 12" size because I can use it to play with my puppy and not get nipped. They're not smelly at all, but I actually wouldn't care so much if they were. They are lasting forever. I am buying a holer for them that I hope works as a nice little handle

These were a definite hit with our girls! They wiggled their tails the entire time chewing on the sticks. The product didn't stain or leave any mess on the floors. I'm so happy with this product and it came within a day! Your pups will love them. Very high quality and a perfect size for large dogs. Love Love Love

My Westie loves these. Much better than rawhide sticks. non-messy, and lasts a long time for a dog her size. She is an aggressive chewer.

Expensive, and not always odor free. But the “Boy” loves them so what are you going to do.

Both my gsd life these and the price was perfect at time of trying. Ordered 2. As they r just a good as bully sticks.

My dog loves these treats and there is no odor. I cut them in thirds for her and give her one each night or if we are going to leave her for a few hours.

I have these on reorder because my dog loved them and gets one a day. I initially liked these because there was low odor compared to bully sticks with the same chew time and convenience at a lower price.Lately the quality has been hit or miss. As you can see, one or both of the ends can 'bloom' and become brittle. The dog loses interest once this happens.The size is also getting more inconsistent. Some are too thick for our medium holder (I use our yak cheese holder for those). I had to get a small holder to accommodate the thin sticks, which there seems to be more of now. We've had a couple sticks over multiple bags that were a little too thin for the small holder. Usually you can find a spot in the middle of the stick that secures in the holder; now at the risk of a double end bloom/frustrating release when it's done.I also had one bag over the summer that STANK! worse than bully sticks. Though the dog still ate them.

My little cockapoo loves these. I get him the 12in. It's adorable. So big. But he just loves chewing on these. And they are so good for him. Good for his 2 year old teeth too. Just started brushing his teeth. But having a good healthy stick is great for dogs oral health. Give it a go. Worth the price. And they last ( depending if u have a small, large, and /or aggressive chewer) Buddy Lou is aggressive with his stick only, buy he is 32lbs so lasta a bit longer than say an aggressive 70lb dog.