Feadog Whistle, Black Pro (FW26P)

After a lot of research (and checking out reviews from very talented musicians on YouTube of various Tin Whistles), I decided to go with this one, based on their input and what type of sound I liked the most of the similar beginner or starter tin whistles. One of the things mentioned about this particular model is that it is more sensitive to your breathing than some typical starter Tin Whistles. I didn't understand that until I got this one and started playing, but I understand now. While the fact that it is so sensitive to your breathing patterns and steadiness could be a negative to some (it makes it slightly harder as a beginner to have your attempts as songs sound halfway decent), it is good overall because it makes it easier to catch improper breathing (and forces you to begin learning good habits from the beginning). There is no seam along the back of the barrel, like some tin whistles (which I like), and it has a good weight feel (especially compared to the more basic whistles I've gotten my children starting on). Overall, I couldn't be happier with this as my first/starter whistle, and I think if/when I gain more skill, it will still be very enjoyable to listen to. Add on the price, and I consider this to be quite a win!

I’m a beginner to the tin whistle, but played the modern concert flute for about ten years when I was younger. I think I got lucky in choosing this Feadog Pro D whistle as my first whistle. I like the feel of it in my hands, as it’s just a bit weightier, though not by much, than the Clarke and Generation whistles. I think this whistle is very responsive to breath pressure (sensitive), and developing a consistent, clear tone will definitely evolve the more you practice. So try not to get discouraged if you have a little trouble at first. This whistle is capable of producing really clear, bright sounds versus the breathy, somewhat muffled sounds I’ve experienced with the Clarke whistles. My ear definitely prefers the voice of this Feadog Pro D. I highly recommend the Feadog Pro D in black brass and encourage you to stick with one whistle for a few months during your learning phase as a beginner.

There are so many tin whistles in this very low price range. MOST of them are decent enough for hobbyists and beginners, and some even play well enough to gig with. The Feadog whistles are nice and one of the more common ones available. THIS one was a few more bucks and for some reason played even nicer than my other Feadog I paid less for. The whistle itself is just slightly, slightly heavier (thicker walled) and so there's a touch more weight to it-hardly noticeable, but indeed different. The timbre is uniformly cleaner and clearer. I had an easier time reaching the upper octave, and frankly I think this one takes less effort to control the notes. You MAY not notice the difference immediately, but you'll notice it once you play it for a few songs. I liked the general "feel" in my hands, and maybe that had to do with the weight IDK? Really though I think the difference with these inexpensive whistles is the quality of the fipple. If the fipple is nice, the notes will sound well, and they'll also be easier and more enjoyable to play. That's why I like the Clarke Sweetone so much, and the Woodi. This Feadog is no doubt as good as ANY whistle I have in this price range.

I love this tin whistle so much that I've bought it four times. It has a crisp, clear and beautiful sound and it's loud, making it perfect for sessions. I do not recommend it for beginners.

good sturdy inexpensive whistle.

This whistle is far more responsive than similar whistles in the price range, with a much less shrill sound. It is the easiest to play in the high g to b range of my whistles, and It plays very well In Tune. It is the beginner whistle I would suggest, without hesitation.

I’ve played many whistles and used to have a Susato Low D, Generations and many others. I decided to relearn and got this and a Clarke. The Clarke is junk, this one is great. Sounds good and easy to play.

Intonation, Tuning Off, Easily Squeaks. I habe played other IrishbWhistles and had none of the issues I had with this model. I wasn't expecting a Kilarney at this price but something is just off about this whistle. Squeak is mouthpiece issue. All inexpensive whistles are mass produced so you can buy one and it plays great, tuning is good and no squeaking but you could buy the same whistle and just get a lemon. When there were music stores you could play several amd find one that worked great but ordering cheap brand online is crap shoot.