essenceBye Bye Panda Eyes Tubing Mascara | Smudge-proof, Volumizing Definition | Vegan, Cruelty Free, Free From Parabens & Oils (Pack of 1)ClimatePartner certified

This stuff is amazing. Doesn't smudge most of the time unless I'm getting real sweaty. I wear it on my 12 hour vet tech shifts and it only gives me little rings under my eyes when I've been deep cleaning the clinic and working up a sweat.It defines my lashes and gives me more value and a little length. My lashes are already long, so I dont need a ton of help, just need darkening and thickening, which this mascara does. Would definitely recommend to a friend.

Easy to apply and covers all lashes evenly. Lasts all day with no smudging which is fantastic! Huge plus - Able to buy 3 for the price of my former brand!

Not a bad drugstore mascara. I usually use Tarte tubing but decided to try this bc I live all my other essence products. It gives good length on the first coat but not much volume. I'm ok with that tho bc I don't like a very thick formula. Probably multiple coats will give more volume (I'm only wearing one coat on the left eye in this pic). I find they get too messy n clumpy when its a thicker formula so I like this one so far. I like the wand on this mascara too. It gives good definition and separation. Hopefully it wears well. I cant speak on that yet but I'll be back for an updated review ....

This is NOT a tubing mascara, don't get mislead by the name, like I was. The mascara itself is actually not bad, I would even say pretty nice (that's why I'm giving it 3 stars instead of one). It goes on smooth, no clumping, great separation, decent length. If tubing effect wasn't important to me, I would be very happy with it and wouldn't be returning it. It gives nice wispy lash effect that I prefer, and you can layer it for a more dramatic/glam look. BUT! When you attempt to remove it, you discover that it's not a tubing mascara. Tubing mascara is supposed to slide off your lashes in little tubes and wash off clean. This one washes off like a traditional mascara, with smudges and black mess spreading around your eyes. So, back it goes.

I saw someone mention this mascara online. I had been wearing waterproof mascara because it didn't smudge during the day. However, it was a pain to take off at night, and the skin around my eyes was getting irritated when I removed it. Anyway, someone said that this stayed smudge free while still being easy to remove. For the price, I thought it was worth a try. I'm glad I bought it! I don't get raccoon eyes during the day, and it comes off with my regular face wash. I don't need to scrub with any eye makeup remover beforehand. I will definitely buy this again.

It’s pretty, it’s a nice, deep shade of black. However, after trying it twice, both on my wedding day, and during a work day, it failed me both times. Both times it smudged and transferred my eyes/lower lash area, and I only applied to my upper lashes. I also used a setting spray over top of it, which sadly didn’t help prevent it from transferring either. Unfortunately I will have keep looking for something else that can actually hold up

Good mascara for the price. It is easier on my lashes due to the tubing effect. I don’t apply much mascara but this bottle has lasted me longer than most.

This mascara is amazing for any occasion. It gives a natural look and also shows at the same time, which is the perfect combo for everyday wear. Comes off easily but lasts the whole day, and you don't need too much. This is my favorite mascara EVER! It also is cheap without the cheap look.