Covergirl Clump Crusher Water Resistant Mascara, Black Brown, 1 x 0.44 Fl Oz

This is my go to mascara and itll never change. I've tried others since and still havent found any to beat it. The applicator works wonderfully to bust clumps and evenly coat my lashes. It adds volume, a little curl (though I naturally have longer curled lashes being a redhead I need mascara for them to be seen lol), and doesnt make the lashes stick together like other brands I've tried. It removes easily but is water resistant enough to stay in place and not smudge if you get teary or have a little itch. My only complaint is, being a redhead, I have to really cover every inch of my lashes to get the full effect, and inevitably end up getting some on my eyelids. This is only partly because of the brush design and mostly because of me. But I wouldn't change it, other brushes cause clumps and spider leg look to my lashes. I take a q-tip to clean up any mistakes at the end and it still looks great!

Easily comes off and looks nice upon application. Have yet to find a smudge proof and water proof mascara though

Covers without clumps!

These two mascaras arrived in already-opened packages and completely empty. The mascara's packages were already opened, and just barely glued together. As soon as I pulled it out of the package, it fell apart. The mascaras themselves were clean, but emptied and completely dry. Amazon was very prompt about refunding me the cost of this item, but the original packaging is a big STAY AWAY.

The package arrived with one mascara tube rather than the two listed in the description. I opened and used it before I realized that two should have come.

I think it is just too light, barely looks like I have it on.

Description and photos do not reflect what is actually sent

The application wand scratched my eye lids. Not a good product. Unsafe. But I did return the item and got my money back. Excellent customer service.